Critique

[gemfyre]

Yeah, I downloaded Idol shit so I could listen and judge. :p

I hate how they have to sing truncated songs, if they took all the bullshit padding out of the show maybe they'd have time to sing entire songs.

Shannon really does nothing for me. Strictly, strictly mediocre. He sings, but I don't hear any talent there. *yawns*

Cosima's voice held up pretty damn well until that last song. Maybe because You Don't Have To Say You Love Me doesn't require as much effort, because that sounded great, but trying a Tina Turner song when your voice is fucked? Not gonna happen.

Nancy!! What song did you sing in the audition? If you get through for Idol 2 I will watch and vote for you. :)

*skedaddles off to uni*

Comments

[logansrogue.livejournal.com]

I did "Emotions" by the BeeGees. FAR too soft. Next time I'm doing a belter.